Where NOT to hastily site an Industrial-scale Wind Energy Project
Just north of Great Basin National Park, east of Ely in Eastern Nevada, lies a public landscape called Spring Valley.
Spring Valley is a miraculous place, renowned for its magnificent skies and as critical habitat for sagebrush obligate species such as sage grouse and pygmy rabbit.
Unfortunately, like so many obscure public places around the west, the innumerable environmental values Spring Valley harbors are under threat, ironically by so-called “green energy” projects.
Spring Valley Wind, LLC, a subsidiary of Pattern Energy of San Francisco, is proposing to build a wind farm called the Spring Valley Wind Project. The Project’s claimed generation capacity is 149.1 megawatts and would be constructed on 8,565 acres of public lands in north Spring Valley.
Investors for this industrial-scale development have pressured BLM to approve the project on a “fast-track” in order meet a time-frame necessary to receive subsidized funding appropriated by the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act. The project’s investors have secured congressional support, bringing high level political pressure straight to the managers on the ground (Senator Harry Reid letter to BLM manager ). The pressure in support of “fast-tracked” approval for “green-energy” projects is ironically targeted at avoiding the full and appropriate environmental review required by NEPA, one of our country’s most critical environmental statutes codifying sound wisdom directing land-managers to “look before you leap” when making decisions that impact the environment.
An appropriate level of review identifies environmental, cultural, and other values present on the proposed landscape, analyzes the proposal’s impact and evaluates whether siting of a given project is appropriate given a range of alternatives which may include alternative siting that avoids conflict with those identified environmental and cultural values. Why plow through intact wildlife habitat and native artifacts if there is a landscape with equal wind development potential that is of lesser quality habitat without known cultural sites ?
On October 15, 2010 rather than conducting thoughtful (and lawful) review, buckling to economic and political pressures, the Bureau of Land Management hastily issued a final decision authorizing the Spring Valley wind project on the “fast-track”.
Spring Valley Wind
Spring Valley Wind intends to grade almost 30 miles of new roads, construct an operations and maintenance building and substation, a new gravel pit, and make many other irretrievable disturbances to sage grouse, pygmy rabbit, and other wildlife habitat that would significantly impact and alter the natural character of this public landscape.
The 400-foot-tall turbines proposed will obscure the viewshed of Great Basin National Park (Wheeler Peak is clearly visible from the site), abuts the Swamp Cedar Area of Critical Environmental Concern and will potentially disturb Native American burial sites.
In the Snake Range just a few miles from the proposed wind development lies the Rose Guano Cave, important habitat for over a million Brazillian free-tailed bats that migrate through the area. A growing body of science demonstrates that wind turbines kills bats by the thousands. The sudden change of air pressure surrounding wind turbines is responsible for Barotrauma, an abrupt explosion of blood vessels in the lungs of bats causing them to drown in their own blood.
The impacts to migratory birds including robins and many raptors is equally appalling and demonstrates that when analysis of the appropriateness of siting is “fast-tracked”, the actual environmental consequences of Wind Energy can lie in stark contrast to the industry’s Public Relations slogans characterizing Wind Energy as “green”.
What’s more, particularly on this public landscape, the construction of the turbines will permanently degrade and obstruct the remarkable views in Spring Valley, permanently obscuring the hidden character of this remarkable place.
For more info read :
Basin & Range Watch’s ‘Spring Valley Wind Project’ webpage, updates, Fall Photo Gallery
November 29, 2010 at 7:37 PM
This is very upsetting to me. It’s right in the prettiest part of Spring Valley.
Harry Reid must have a real animosity to this part of Nevada. He teamed up with the Southern Nevada Water Authority to try to drain Spring valley and adjacent Snake Valley dry. Of course, his economic model is to keep Las Vegas growing unsustainably forever.
They seem to be beaten back on the water issue for the time being. There are many stories of the battle on this blog.
November 30, 2010 at 9:56 AM
His votes are in Las Vegas and Reno…
This is the kind of fight that must just tickle the anti environmental crowd to no end..to have lands and species folks against ” green energy” folks Same thing is happening in the San Luis Valley in Colorado…Crestone, Alamosa, Poncha Spring..Gorgeous mountain valley with the Sangres on one side, and the San Juans on the other as you drive down this valley. They have tons of water, and tons of sunshine, and it is a poor agricultural area, so the solar folks have been quietly buying up senior water rights, and offering to buy land that is lying fallow, or is being used for potato farming–marginal living at best. The solar companies are selling the idea of the “job” myth to the locals. The reality, of course, is very few possess the skills to work in the higher paying jobs, and if there are jobs for them, they will be custodial in nature for the most part. There are a few local groups fighting it, but I fear they are going to be overwhelmed.
November 30, 2010 at 10:28 AM
I agree with your post above. Solar farms in the pastoral San Juan Valley would be a visual disaster.
It seems these green technologies are happening in so many places – actually for private profit to energy markets outside the states where the power is generated. Anywhere turbines (or in the case of the San Juan solar) can be installed – along the Snake River above Lewiston, near Ellensburg, WA, along the Columbia in a couple of spots.
Footnote: My recollection of the San Luis Valley is that they do not have tons of water, and outside interests are all trying to snag it. I guess I shared my story here before about the San Juan Baca Grande Ranch (south of Crestone) and the proposal of a private water development company who wanted to suck the massive artesian aquifer beneath the ranch and the valley (including Great Sand Dunes National Monument) dry, pump it into the South Platte Basin and sell it to water starved Denver.