In April, Ralph contrasted the disproportionate media hysteria that takes place when a wolf kills a cow or sheep versus when any number of other natural events result in vastly more significant livestock loss. The example that he used :
SE Montana blizzard kills far more livestock in 2 days than Montana wolves in a year :
cattle losses to wolves in Montana in 2008 totaled just 77 dead with a couple dozen more “probables.”
Another more recent example of the glaring disparity of livestock loss to wolves & environment versus the weather is aptly illustrated on the other end of the weather spectrum :
Extreme heat kills hundreds of cattle in Nebraska - AP
In southeastern Nebraska’s Hamilton County, temperatures in the 90s and high humidity contributed to the deaths of roughly 600 cattle.
That’s one county.


July 2, 2009 at 7:02 AM
BE and RM,
thanks for continuing to post these stories. It allows more “average” folks to see how stupid the hysteria around wolves is. They are certainly a great eye opening example of how much political clout livestock groups have. Maybe un-politically corrupt politicians will one day notice as well…
thanks again for your effort to keep us all informed.
July 2, 2009 at 7:15 AM
We have to keep spreading word about the relative numbers. The other day Montana Cattlemen’s Association took out a full page ad in the Missoulian showing “gory”* photos of livestock and sheepdogs that had been attacked (some surviving and others as carcasses) by wolves.
- – - -
*These photos were intended to shock urban dwellers, although anyone who works with livestock would find a dead cow or an animal in severe distress a routine sight.
Apparently the area where the two Oregon wolves recently killed about 20 sheep was found to have nearby a carcass dump (also called a “bone field”) covering several acres.
July 2, 2009 at 9:49 AM
The folks I talk to think that a 1-2% loss each year on their herds for all causes (predators, bloat, lightening, etc) is normal and expected. Given herd sizes, that might be a pretty big number.